Building Authentic Brand Connections on Social Media in a Post-Algorithm World

The social media rules of engagement are constantly being rewritten. The shift toward algorithm-driven feeds, where paid content is prioritized, has made it increasingly more work for brands to connect with their audiences organically. In this post-algorithm world, brands must rethink strategies to foster genuine engagement and build authentic connections with followers. 

This article explores practical strategies for maintaining and enhancing brand relationships on social media, even as organic reach declines.

The Changing Landscape of Social Media

When social media was still new, platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter offered a level playing field where brands and individuals could organically reach their audiences. However, as these platforms have grown, they’ve implemented algorithms designed to prioritize content that keeps users engaged—often favoring paid posts and advertisements over organic content. As a result, brands are finding it harder to cut through the noise and connect with their audience without investing heavily in paid campaigns.

While this shift poses challenges, it also allows brands to differentiate themselves by focusing on authenticity and meaningful engagement. Here’s how brands can adapt to this new reality and build lasting connections with their audience.

Free Resource

Unlocking Engagement: Celebrating Subscriber Milestones for Lasting Connections

DOWNLOAD NOW

1. Prioritize Authentic Storytelling

In a post-algorithm world, authentic storytelling is more important than ever. Audiences are increasingly drawn to content that feels genuine and relatable. To build authentic brand connections, share stories that resonate with your audience’s values, experiences, and aspirations. This could involve:

• Highlighting Customer Stories: Share testimonials, case studies, or user-generated content that showcases real experiences with your brand. This creates trust among your brand and followers, and allows your audience to see themselves in the stories you share.
• Behind-the-Scenes Content: Give a glimpse into the inner workings of your brand. Whether it’s a day in your team’s life, the creative process behind a new product, or the challenges you face, behind-the-scenes content humanizes your brand and fosters a deeper connection.
• Authentic Brand Voice: Develop a brand voice that reflects your company’s values and personality. Consistency is critical whether your tone is playful, serious, or inspirational. Your audience should feel like they’re interacting with a real person, not a faceless corporation.

2. Engage with Your Audience Meaningfully

One of the most effective ways to build authentic connections is by actively engaging with your audience. Rather than treating social media as a one-way broadcast channel, view it as a platform for two-way communication. This means:

• Engage with Comments and Messages: Don’t ignore comments and messages. Acknowledge your audience’s input, whether positive or negative and show that you value their feedback.
• Starting Conversations: Use your content to spark meaningful conversations. Ask questions, encourage discussions, and invite your audience to share their thoughts on relevant topics. The more engaged your audience feels, the more likely they will stay connected with your brand.
• Participating in Social Listening: Monitor social media channels by looking for mentions of your brand, competitors, or industry-related topics. By paying attention to what your audience is saying, you can gain valuable insights and join conversations in a way that feels organic and relevant.

3. Harness User-Generated Content

When your audience sees other users sharing their experiences with your brand, it reinforces the idea that your products or services are worth discussing. To effectively leverage UGC:

• Encourage Sharing: Give your followers a reason to share their experiences with your brand. This could be through hashtags, contests, or with a simple ask of tagging your brand in their posts.
• Feature UGC on Your Channels: Showcase user-generated content on your social media profiles. This will not only highlight your customers but also create a sense of community around your brand.
• Acknowledge and Reward Contributors: Show appreciation to those who create and share content about your brand. This could be through shoutouts, featuring their content in your marketing materials, or offering incentives like discounts or giveaways.

4. Embrace Transparency and Authenticity

In an era where trust in institutions and corporations wanes, transparency has become a brand’s key differentiator. Being open and honest with your audience can lay a groundwork of trust that leads to long-term loyalty. Strategies to enhance transparency include:

• Open Communication: Be upfront about your brand’s values, mission, and business practices. Whether it’s sustainability efforts, sourcing practices, or company culture, share the information that matters to your audience.
• Addressing Mistakes: If your brand makes a mistake, own up to it. Apologize sincerely, and I will outline your steps to rectify the situation. This level of accountability can strengthen your brand’s reputation and reinforce your commitment to your customers.
• Showing the Human Side of Your Brand: Highlight the people behind your brand. Share stories about your employees, celebrate their achievements, and showcase the diversity and culture within your company. 

5. Build a Community Around Your Brand

Creating a sense of community is essential for fostering long-term engagement. When your audience feels part of a community, loyalty grows. Here’s how to build a strong community:

• Create Exclusive Groups: Consider creating private groups on platforms like Facebook or LinkedIn where your most engaged followers can connect with your brand. These groups can serve as a space for discussions, exclusive content, and direct feedback.
• Host Live Events: Live streaming events, Q&A sessions, or webinars provide an opportunity for real-time interaction with your audience. These events offer value, strengthen the sense of community, and make your brand more accessible.
• Celebrate Milestones Together: Recognize and celebrate your community’s achievements and milestones. Whether it’s reaching a follower count, launching a new product, or celebrating an anniversary, involve your audience in the celebration to reinforce their connection to your brand.

6. Balance Paid and Organic Strategies

While organic reach is declining, it doesn’t mean that organic strategies should be abandoned. Instead, brands should strike a balance between paid and organic efforts. Here’s how to do it effectively:

• Invest in High-Quality Content: Focus on creating content that your audience can value and encourages organic engagement. High-quality, relevant content can still attract organic interactions even in a paid-driven landscape.
• Use Paid Campaigns Strategically: Paid campaigns should complement your organic efforts rather than replace them. Use paid ads to amplify your best-performing content, reach new audiences, and drive specific actions, such as website visits or product purchases.
• Test and Optimize: Continuously test different content formats, messaging, and targeting options to find what works best for your brand. Use insights from both paid and organic efforts to refine your strategy and maximize your impact.

Building authentic brand connections on social media requires a strategic and thoughtful approach in a post-algorithm world. As social media continues to evolve, those brands that focus on authenticity and meaningful engagement will thrive in this new landscape.

Author Bio:

by Natalie Slyman

Content Marketing Manager